Seeking opinion on fan control switch

Jasco makes both of those and just puts a different brand name on them. They may have a few slightly different features and slightly different firmware, but they are essentially the same device.

The following community FAQ lists the various fan control alternatives that people have used. You might find it interesting. (Although it says Alexa in the topic title, the same solution applies whether you are using a voice assistant or not)

FAQ: 2020 Ceiling Fan and Dimmer light wall mount control compatible with SmartThings and Alexa?