That is a really good assumption, but @fido hasn’t mentioned that any of the speakers are on S2 firmwares.
He has Play:1 and Play:5 speakers. Only the Play:5 (Gen 2) has received the S2 firmware, the Gen 1 works only with S1.
And if you have any which is S1 only, it is a better choice to keep all of them on S1 if you want to use them together. As far as I know, you cannot mix S1 and S2 speakers in multi-speaker setup, if you want them to “Play” together.