are you saying if you change the setting to Always, close the screen, go back to that screen that the setting has changed to While using the app? or does it change over a longer time frame?
you know we are going to ask you to post what versions you have for both
under settings > privacy > location services > system services → check that nothing obvious has been disabled?
any other apps showing as Always on her iPhone… just checking if it is only limited to the ST app.
The same thing was happening with my wife’s iPhone 6s. I finally gave up and migrated to the new Smartthings app, but with this one even though the setting stays at “Always” the presence detection isn’t working. This is very very annoying, since most of my automations key off whether or not anyone is at home.