A hope and a prayer- we changed the decor in our kitchen, and now all the paddle switches are white instead of ivory. I wasn’t smart enough to save the white paddle replacement. If you had one, I could Venmo you the money. I think it would fit in a regular envelope with one stamp ($0.72) for shipping.
I see I’m not the first to come here looking for this. Also, I can send you the ivory paddle if you want it!
Worth a try! Thanks for reading.