Migration to V2 - Hurdles and Best Practices

It’s legit I can tell you all, and I did it alone :smile:

To be fair, I was under duress, since I was leaving my DC home for the move to CA and had to get it done in time to catch a flight.

Warning. tl;dr string of free flowing thoughts below, but I wanted to be open and share my own experiences.

My approach was pretty simple. I unplugged my V1 Hub, plugged in V2 and set it up as a brand new Location. I tackled Zigbee devices first because of the better range, which means all of my door and motion sensors. Those simply need to be reset while the new Hub is in pairing mode, and I’m pretty practiced with our own devices. That went super quick.

Then on to Z-wave in wall switches which was the majority by raw numbers. I then proceeded room by room, emanating outwards from my Hub in order to build the Z-wave mesh reasonably well.

Upon entering each room, I would go to Location Settings -> Hub -> Z-wave utilities -> General Exclude and remove all Z-wave devices in the room in a sweep. Takes about 15 seconds per device. I’d then enter pairing and pair them into the new Hub, naming the devices and putting them in a new corresponding V2 Room while doing it. I only ran into switches in the far reaches of the house, but found that by cycling those switches manually a few times while Hub was in general exclude they would eventually get pushed out. I could have gone faster if I’d been smart enough to use the Aeon Minimote to do the exclusions since signal range wouldn’t have been an issue then joining would have used the full mesh already getting built out.

To be honest, I was surprised at how quickly this part went and would certainly run into issues if I hadn’t been careful/lucky with my radiating distance from the Hub since if I had started at an edge I might have been able to remove a device and have trouble pairing it to the new Hub.

My final steps were the locks. I had the master codes on hand so those took about a minute each.

That’s it in terms of setting up the raw network. The 3 hours did not include full setup of SmartApps, Routines, Modes, etc. Those I did remotely after thinking about how I wanted to approach things using all the new functionality in the V2 app. Smart Home Monitor takes about 2 minutes to install since you can sweep in all of your door/window and motion sensors as a default setting. Leaks, Floods, Smoke all even easier.

The more nuanced decision making came up when considering the new Smart Lighting tools and how I wanted to intersect that with Routines. E.g. did I want my porch lights to come on at sunset via SL or do that with a Routine. Overall I netted out taking care of specific lights and groups of lights with Smart Lighting, and then took care of broad settings like turning off all the lights (and locking doors and arming Smart Home Monitor) upon departure using Routines and Mode changes.

Anyhow that was my own path, probably 5 hours all-in (3 for device pairing and 2 for setup of automations), but I’m up pretty high on the knowledge scale.

We know it sucks not to have a migration tool yet, and are working on it even though there aren’t clear ways anyone in the world has been able to do it with Zigbee, etc. and we actually don’t want to do a 1:1 matching for SmartApps ever since there are such better ways of accomplishing automation given how our platform has evolved over the past 6 months in particular.

I made the call to get V2 out the door despite this since it felt better to enable the rapidly expanding community to access the new functionality vs. wait for the migration tool. We do plan to get one developed by the end of the year, and it is incrementally important since it will also help people who have a Hub that breaks down for some reason and needs to be replaced.

I also know a few of the bugs / design changes that didn’t make it in for 9/3 are important. For example, the lack of a header that collapses upon scrolling in the Rooms and Things views on Android (vs. iOS where it does collapse). Another example is Device Sets, which will be a far superior method of grouping lights together that is meant to fully eliminate the Lights and Switches module on the dashboard. But we are a global company now and it was time to get this out the door and in your hands. It is a huge improvement, particularly for people who are just getting started.

The improvements will be rapid from here. Already an iOS update moving through the approval queue and Android will get an important update addressing top issues this week. We then plan weekly polishing releases for at least the next month or more. Software is easier to iterate and we have much more scale now than in the past, vs. the full release which included an incredible amount of stuff (Hub, video platform, new devices, new certification program, Smart Home Monitor, fully revamped apps on both iOS and Android, our first international expansion) all at once.

I’m incredibly proud of the SmartThings team and our efforts right now. The passion going into making this the most easy and open smart home platform in the world is awe inspiring. I hope the evolution of the products makes that clear and that you all appreciate it even while we work through issues.

Alex