VLC Thing. A Poor Man's Sonos. Version 2.0 Released 12/22/2016

Hah, I completely understand! Even tied to a desk job, and working from a home office I have a hard time to find the time to fit in projects like this :slight_smile:

One more thing… you may already know this but thought I pass it along.

I use a combination of VNC and Filezilla to remotely manage all my RPi’s. This allows me to operate everything headless (no monitor, keyboard, or mouse). VNC gives you a virtual desktop on my windows desktop for each RPi and Fillazilla allows me to transfer files between all the devices devices — such as adding new sounds or changing old ones.

I VNC in to the pi too! I ordered a wifi dongle to get this moved out of my office and into the middle of the house so everyone can appreciate when I come home and the theme song of Sanford and Son plays and when my wife comes home Crambone from good 'ol Tom and Jerry’s Uncle Pecos sings. :grinning:

I got VLC thing working with Big Talker. I defin have a clipping issue and its pretty random. My PC that i’m using is wired ethernet and just using my computer speakers (3.5mm), it clips…

Backend issue still? Anything we can do from a setting perspective to reduce the clipping?

Once I switched from HDMI to bluetooth the problem disappeared. If I switch back the problem returns. I can only surmise an issue between VLC and the driver. Folks on the VLC forum were non responsive to the issue and I didn’t have the patience to open a problem report with VLC . I think that’s the next step if we really want it resolved properly.

To be clear I am not blaming HDMI, I believe it’s the particular driver I have that handles the HDMI connection. So whatever is wrong could be wrong with any driver. Maybe you can select a different one for your speakers or try a different set of speakers as well.

It’s just odd that a wired connection like HDMI would be the laggy issue for the clipping. High bandwidth connection with low lag.

Bluetooth has delay and bandwidth issues of it’s own. but maybe the delay is enough so there is no clipping. I guess I’ll have to pair a bluetooth speaker to my computer and have VLC output sound to it.

I suppose vlc can be the issue too.

bmac6996 https://community.smartthings.com/users/bmac6996
February 14

It’s just odd that a wired connection like HDMI would be the laggy issue
for the clipping. High bandwidth connection with low lag.

Bluetooth has delay and bandwidth issues of it’s own. but maybe the delay
is enough so there is no clipping. I guess I’ll have to pair a bluetooth
speaker to my computer and have VLC output sound to it.

I suppose vlc can be the issue too.

Agreed , I don’t think it’s a hardware issue I believe it’s likely some
sort of driver issue that VLC is struggling with.

I have VLC running on a dedicated Windows 10 computer. What is the URI needed to play a local file? I tried using the file:// protocol but no luck.

I remember reading somewhere it needed /// (3 forward or backward slashes?), now I’m not sure if that was a windows host though :slight_smile:

Hi I’m having some trouble setting this up. I have the handler and vice installed and can’t seem to get it to connect. Having trouble finding my port I think. Could you help me?

Thanks. You gave me a clue and I figured it out. 3 slashes did the trick, like file:///c:/sounds/doorbell.mp3

This command line help confirmed it:
https://wiki.videolan.org/VLC_command-line_help/

@geko, I have this working, and it is coming from my computer speakers, is there a way to use ChromeCast or Alexa without having to go and open a developer account on Amazon? I am a little lost with the Media renderer thing. I just would like sound from different places in my home.

Also the computer I am using has both LAN and WiFi, does it matter which I use? Also any hints on eliminating the lag, or the times it doesn’t respond. I turned off sleep for the HD, so I am hoping that will work.

Your computer sound is dependent on what speakers you have connected. If it has Bluetooth connectivity you can add those.

Thank you for that. What about which way to connect, WiFi or LAN? And why is there times that the speech is cut off or stats in the middle? If I did something wrong how do I correct this? Thanks again.

Vlc is a program that runs on your computer so whatever sound output your computer is set on thats where you will get the sound.(example: I have the VLC program running on 2 computers- One is connected to wired speakers via the headphone jack and the other is connect to bluetooth speaker)
If you do something wrong you can always uninstall and reinstall the program.(VLC).
VLC thing is the device that you have installed in your Smartthings app, its like a remote controller for your VLC installed on your computer.
Scroll up and you will find many discusssions about speech cutoffs.
If you have Wifi speakers and you prefer to use those then its best to use the Mediarenderer instead of VLC thing

OK I have to do some research, I am thinking about getting a Samsung Speaker. The mediarenderer is hardware, which replaces VLC, is that correct?

Now how do you run two VLCs as the app on phone asks for IP.? Do you run two remotes on your phone one for each?

MediaRenderer is a a ST smartapp that uses a DLNA speaker to playback sound and music, just like VLC.
If you get Samsung speakers that are supported by ST then you dont need mediarenderer nor vlc. you control it via ST.
Sonos is another way to go.
Yes I run 2 VLC things in ST pointing to the 2 different addresses

Thank you for the detailed answer, then the Samsung speaker is the way to go. The range of my Bluetooth speaker is horrible, so the Samsung is the way for me to go.

FYI folks have been saying Sonos is better than Samsung with ST integration.
You are welcome

OK I am interested in your thoughts. I want the best integration I can get at a reasonable cost. The Sonos doesn’t need a hub it is stand alone? Will the Play 1 work?

With all due respect, how’s Sonos discussion relevant to VLC Thing? Could you please take your discussion to the Sonos thread? Thanks!