This thread is just intended as a list of the buttons and switches that work with SmartThings, not for individual discussion or recommendations. ( otherwise it becomes too hard to read.) You will notice that the individual posts generally have a link to a thread where you can ask follow on questions about a specific device.
Otherwise, start a new thread under projects and people will be glad to give you advice About your particular set up .
Alternatively, you might just want to read the following thread (this is a clickable link) which is recent and describes a very similar situation to yours:
But again, take follow up questions to that thread, so we can keep this FAQ thread focused on device listings. Thanks.