Door / window sensors


I’m trying to get some guidance on alternative Door / window sensors that will work with the Samsung smartthings system. I have a number of devices that Samsung sell for the home automation system but I don’t want to spend 29.99 for every window and door in my house or I’ll need to remortgage my home.

Thank you

I use a lot of iris contact sensors. They are cheaper in price and still reliable. They go on sale at Lowe’s every now and then.

1 Like

You need to prioritize. Are you going to concentrate on automation or security ? Nobody says you need to put sensors on 30 windows and 4 doors, motion in every room at once. You will find that people build up in stages. I’ve been piecemealing mine together for over 3 years. I did not go out and try and get 200 devices at once. This lets you play around and decide what you really want. I guarantee that as you build up you will change your mind. Decide things you thought you needed are not that important , and also automate things you never dreamed you would.

1 Like

My next stage is security as home automation has been taken care of, have you any recommendations ?

Use a different system? :wink:

Everyone has different priorities and requirements for a home security system. Many of us in the community (myself included) use a completely different system for home security than SmartThings.

In my case, I have several minimum requirements for the home security system:

One) it be able to send notifications when either power or Internet are out

(SmartThings relies on The Internet to send notifications, even push notifications to your phone – – it has no cellular communication option )

  1. it communicate with a monitoring Center that can dispatch fire as well as police response

(the paid service that SmartThings integrates with, scout, can only dispatch police, not fire)

  1. it have a customizable entrance and entry delay for the security system

(Smart Home Monitor does not, and if you use custom code to introduce one, it again will not work unless the smartthings cloud is available since custom code cannot run locally)

  1. it provides a means for arming/disarming the system if the Internet is not available

(SmartThings does not)

  1. It allow me to postpone any system updates until the time of my choosing.

(Smartthings does not, even for updates which will take the system off-line temporarily)

  1. it has a maintenance free operating period of at least six months and preferably a year.

I have a security system which meets all of the above. It has worked well for about 10 years. The only thing I don’t like about it is that I feel I pay a little too much on a monthly basis. But having now gotten much more precise about my requirements and investigated many of the less expensive systems, I feel a little better about what I’m getting given that the cheaper alternatives, including SmartThings, don’t meet my minimum requirements.

Your own requirements may be very different, so each person has to judge for themselves. Just understand what it is that you’re getting.

SmartThings themselves in their usage guidelines say their system should not be used for anything which might affect safety or security, including protection of valuables. To me, that says it’s not really a good fit for a primary security system, Although you may find it useful as a secondary.

Data accuracy and consistency from SmartThings sensors, including those provided by SmartThings directly, resold by SmartThings, or supported by SmartThings, is not guaranteed.
Therefore, you should not rely on that data for any use that impacts health, safety, security, property or financial interests.
For example, because temperature readings may vary significantly from reading to reading on an individual device, between devices, or over time, those readings should not be used to control heating and cooling in environments where food spoilage, health risks, or damage to physical goods could occur.
Alternately, presence data from SmartThings devices or mobile/Smartphones can vary in accuracy, and therefore should not be used to control access to secure locations without secondary authentication.
SmartThings provides information on the physical state of many devices, including through contact sensors (which may provide open/closed status of windows and doors), accelerometers, locks, appliances, HVAC, light and power fixtures, and presence sensors.
The complexity of combining physical interactions with digital interactions may result in inconsistencies in the representation of the actual state of a device in the physical world in its digital representation.
In all cases, SmartThings does its best to interpret and maintain the state of these devices (including by querying for current data), but this is not intended as a replacement for direct, physical verification in situations where the true state of a device may have an impact on health, safety, security, property or financial interests. For example, you should not assume that a curling iron (which may cause a fire if left on too long) is actually off without physically verifying the state.


Another for IRIS contact sensors.

I agree with @JDRoberts, use a different system. I use SimpliSafe. It’s very affordable to purchase, easy to install, works well and the monthly monitoring is very reasonable with no contract. That said, the integration with ST is just okay, and even then its all community based. SimpliSafe does not seem interested in cooperating with home automation. However, the community device handler does work nicely. My SimpliSafe system is armed whenever everyone leaves my home (or their cell phones do) and disabled whenever anyone comes home, all auto-magically.

While I use SimpliSafe, I’m sure there are many choices, so shop around :slight_smile: