Z-Wave reception is pretty poor

@JDRoberts - Knowledgeable as always :slight_smile: - I had read Zigbee was much more prevalent in Europe but that may have been referred to the Industrial market. I work for a multinational test and automation company so I may have applied what I read for our market to home automation. Either way, it would be best for Scott to use devices that operate on legal bands in the UK… If one must transgress the law, I would do it using a US zigbee rather than a US zwave. My opinion is that it is way harder to get caught causing trouble with a device operating on a legal frequency but at a few mW too many than operating a device on a prohibited band. In reality… the power output is so low that nobody might ever even notice and no harm may ever come from it… but you never know.

Thanks for the responses, folks.
FWIW, my nearest neighbour is around 1/4 mile away so I doubt that I’m either suffering from, nor causing, any kind of interference.
It looks like I’ve swallowed some of the hype re z-wave range too readily and that I’ll need to get a repeater - I have understood the differences between a UK and US repeater and their voltage / physical plug requirements.

I also have a number of zigbee devices (presence detectors and Philips Hue kit) and I believe they will work fine with my US hub.

I’m not inclined to throw the US Hub away - I’ll persevere. My job is half in the UK and half in the US so I have the luxury of being able to buy (or, if it all fails, sell) kit in either country.

Again, thanks for the responses - I’m an electronics engineer and software developer to trade but the whole home-automation thing is new to me.

1 Like

I never knew what it was like without a strong line powered Zwave network.

When I bought into HA, I bout a bunch of Zwave In Wall Hard Wired switches as well as a bunch of plug in switches for various things. Not purposeful to create a mesh but just so happened that I wanted them for various things.

Turns out there is a in wall zwave switch by each of my doors that has a contact sensor in it.So I have never ran into the range issue you experienced here…

Surprised me just how short it is… get a plug in zwave device or switch, put it in there and you’ll be good.

2 Likes

Ordered one - looks like two week delivery so I’ll have a wait to see whether it fixes it!

1 Like

In the meantime, I’ve moved the ST hub to the other side of the living room (rather than being ~6 inches from the wifi / broadband router) and performance seems much improved.

1 Like