Google Home vs. Amazon Echo?

It launches netflix on the cast device itself (the google cast device on the tv). As long as you have a google home, a chrome cast (or google cast enabled device) and netflix linked to google home, it works.

4 Likes

So, got a question for those of you that mentioned your thermostats.

What would you think if you could say, Alexa, tell home it’s too cold downstairs… And you thermostat switches over to heat and adjust the temp accordingly?

Or if you’re hot, it switches to cool and runs.

Or if you turn on the fireplace but want it to go off in ten minutes…

Check out version 3 of EchoSistant… It does all of that and more… Due for release tomorrow night.

Some do that now. I’m happy with my ecobees3 with multiple sensors. I can tell google home to set heat or cool. Or ask what the temp is now. I never asked it I’m cold but I can try. Nope didn’t work but I would rather set temp my self then to say I’m cold and it adjust to whatever. Alexa even with skill enabled struggles with thermostats.

I agree… The native Alexa skill with thermostats definitely had trouble… though it has improved greatly… we’ve got it now working even better…

Alexa, it’s too cold downstairs… Alexa analyzes it and determines what mode it needs to be in and raises or lowers accordingly

2 Likes

Accordingly to it may not be accordingly to me. I rather say set to 70 whatever.

2 Likes

as @JDRoberts says… ā€œChoices are goodā€

You now have the ā€œChoiceā€ to do it how you want…

I like saying it’s cold… my wife likes saying ā€œJason, tell you girlfriend to turn up the heat!ā€

7 Likes

Lmao. At your last comment

1 Like

Me too, especially in the middle of the night when I say Alexa ā€œset upstairs to 70 degreesā€ā€¦only to hear: I found multiple devices named Upstairs, which one did you mean? Upstairs Thermostat.

Alexa: the device is in automode, aiming for 74.
Me: but I said 70
Alexa: silent…

It has happened enough times that it motivated me to fix it with Echosistant. I can tel set to x degrees, I am too hot, or turn it up… Whatever I want, and it just works, without annoyances

1 Like

Were GH shines lol.

2 Likes

I’ve got an Echo, two Dots, and a Google Home and so far, the only downside I’ve encountered with either is that Google Home doesn’t have bluetooth, which means that for now I can’t seem to connect my Samsung Wireless Speakers. Google would prefer that you hook up a Chromecast to the speaker (but mine don’t have an auxiliary input :disappointed:). In terms of using them for home automation and Smartthings, they both work pretty much the same in my experience.

I feel - like others have commented - that the Google Home just ā€œknowsā€ more stuff. I find that I can ask it questions that Alexa doesn’t know the answer to. On the other hand, my wife and I have a ton of content in the Amazon Prime ecosystem (echosystem?) - like prime music - that is very easily accessed via Alexa and streamed wirelessly to our Samsung speakers. If the content isn’t an issue, I’d go with Google Home - on the bet that functionality will greatly increase over the next few months.

2 Likes

Does that speaker have an optical input port on it? If it does, you can get an optical cable to 3.5mm audio jack and you are good to go.

Do you use google wifi as your primary router and how do you like it? Thanks.

I wish!! I have two WAM550s and two 350s and neither model had auxiliary or optical inputs. I think I’m stuck until I’m able to connect to the speakers via wi-fi. Keepin’ my fingers crossed!

With the GH, can I tell it to play an Amazon Prime video on say my PS3 (connected to a TV with a Chromecast)?

Yes I do and I love it. I have extra ones lol.

I have 2 echos and 2 google homes. Google finally released Bluetooth support today. that’s a big bonus… but having more than one device causes a problem, when I say ok google, both start listening, they need to determine which device is closer to the person trying to talk to it, this is very frustrating, this alone makes me keep my echo devices in use more often.

1 Like