ST-compatible RGBW LED Strip Controller Reviews (2020)

There are two different approaches to adding RGBW LED strips to a Samsung SmartThings ™ setup. Since there are now a number of different brands offering choices for both approaches, I thought it was time for a new thread. if you have personal experience with any particular brand/model, specifically with how well they integrate the new V3 smartthings app, please add it to this thread or link to an existing thread.

Since this is 2020, please limit conversations to the new app, although custom code required is fine as long as it works with the V3 app.

  1. Smart LED Strips. Often the easiest way to do this is just to buy smart LED strips. These may look like an RGBW Bulb to smartthings, but will work just fine.

Check product descriptions carefully as these usually come in a starter set which includes the plug-in power module and then offer optional “extension” pieces to make the strips longer. These also typically work off of regular 120V Outlets in the US.

Different brands do have different features. For example, the Wi-Fi LIFX strips require their own gateway and make a cloud To cloud connection, but let you set different parts of a single strip to different colors.

Hue strips Work best with their own bridge but that bridge can form a local connection with smartthings if you have a smartthings hub, or can be used in a cloud to cloud integration if you have SmartThings set up in a “hub optional“ configuration.

Sylvania Smart+ strips can be joined directly to a smart things hub, you don’t need an additional bridge device.

The biggest drawback to this group is their cost.

  1. Dumb strips, smart controller. Sometimes a less expensive option is to use regular dumb LED strips but add a smart controller that can talk to smartthings. (Note that some of these will need to be spliced into the existing wiring and some will need a transformer.)

One of the first of these was the Fibaro RGBW zwave controller. It works very well and has a lot of advanced features, like also being able to accept input from analog sensors. It also allows you to control individual channels separately. It will work directly with smartthings, no additional bridge device required. However, it’s still pretty expensive.

In the last two years we have seen more options that are less expensive, particularly Zigbee 3.0 controllers from Gledopto and Wi-Fi controllers from Sonoff.

The gledopto controllers can be used either with the Hue Bridge or directly with smartthings. They are very popular. they will look like in RGBW bulb to smartthings. Color control is sometimes a little better if you use them with the hue bridge.

Setup for the Sonoff devices Can be technically pretty complicated as many people will “flash the firmware” on these devices in order to let them work directly with smartthings. But if you’re OK with a technical setup process and you want to save some money, these are a very popular choice.

If you are in the US, the Zooz zen31 is a good Z wave option, but it is not available for Europe.

There are many additional brands in this category, but quite a few are inexpensive Chinese knockoff‘s of Sonoff or gledopto and don’t typically have the same safety certifications. Hopefully some of the people who are using well engineered alternatives from other brands will add reviews to this thread. :sunglasses:

Zemismart and RGBGenie are good examples of lesser known brands in this category that seem to have decent engineering. However, community reports have been that color control is not always accurate with these.

========================================
Summary

(I will update this section as reviews are added below.)

Note that most light strips can be cut shorter if desired, but you won’t be able to do anything with the pieces you’ve cut off.

  1. Smart Strips

A.Philips Hue Strips. Require the Hue bridge. Work well. Also works with HomeKit. Expensive.

https://www.bestbuy.com/site/philips-hue-white-and-color-ambiance-80-inch-lightstrip-plus-base-kit-white/6402003.p?skuId=6402003

B. Sylvania Smart+ zigbee strips. Work directly with the smartthings hub, no bridge required. Work well.

C. LIFX . WiFi, even though the model name is “zstrip.” Requires their own gateway. Lets you set different sections of one strip to different colors.

D. Eria. Zigbee 3.0. A newer brand. Can work with the Hue bridge. Says it can also work with the smartthings hub without a bridge, but I haven’t seen anyone confirm that.

E. Aeotec makes a zwave Smart light strip, but it was very expensive and did not sell well in the US. So has become hard to find. Included here for completeness, but not a popular item at this time.

US frequency:

https://www.thesmartesthouse.com/collections/rgbw-and-led-strip-control/products/aeotec-by-aeon-labs-z-wave-plus-rgbw-led-strip-zw121

  1. Smart Controllers for use with Dumb Strips

A. Zooz zen31. US Zwave. A fairly new item, but the smartest house has always been committed to providing smartthings support for their devices. Works directly with a smartthings hub, no additional bridge required. Value priced, especially for a Z wave device.

B. Gledopto zigbee 3.0 controller. Popular budget choice. Works directly with SmartThings, no additional bridge device required. Or if you prefer it can be connected via a Hue bridge if you want additional effects available from the hue app.

C. Sonoff WiFi controller. Requires significant technical skill for set up. No additional bridge device required. Note that product descriptions for the base kit often say it is a “smart LED strip.“ It is not. It is a smart controller with a dumb strip.

D. RGBGenie. Zigbee. Seems to work best with hue bridge, but can be connected directly to smartthings. Some complaints about color accuracy.

E. RGBGenie. Zwave. This is a different model than the zigbee version. Requires custom code. No bridge device required.

E. Zemismart. Zigbee. Connect directly to SmartThings.
(Note that they also have a Wi-Fi model that does not integrate with SmartThings.)

Devices that worked with Classic, but now appear to fail with the new V3 app

A. Fibaro RGBW Controller. Zwave. Many advanced features. This Worked well with the Classic app but required custom code. However, as of September 2020, many people are reporting that it is not working with the new V3 app. Fibaro does not seem to be interested in providing smartthings-specific code. So although it has been very popular, I am removing it from the candidate list for now.

7 Likes

I haven’t used either of these, but a couple other z-wave options for the DIY strips:

Zooz RGBW dimmer

monoprice
https://www.monoprice.com/product?p_id=36511

2 Likes

Thanks @JDRoberts for making this awesome post! Was very helpful.

1 Like

Awesome post!

Anyone know anything about this one?

Looks similar to the Magic Home Controllers

Thanks for the good post!
I’m new to Smartthings, I have to ask this:
Ive heard that people are using two diffrent apps, and I’m going to have the new ST V3 hub , in this case, for Dumb strips, witch Fiabro controller should I use v1 or v2, and with wich ST app?
Can you please clarify this so I know what to do? Thank you!

You should use the newest version of the app. The older app, which is called “SmartThings Classic” will be discontinued in a few months.

Here is that announcement:

And this FAQ explains how to tell which app is which:

FAQ: how to tell which version of the SmartThings mobile app that you have

Thank you for the fast response. And how about the Fibaro rgb controller, wich one should I buy? There are two versions, which works , FGRGBWM-441 or v2 FGRGBWM-442
Thank you!

Does anyone know of any RGBW controllers that will work without the hue bridge for the following scenario: I am trying to have rgb and warm white controlled. I have tried a couple different ones including the Gledopto and haven’t achieved the desired results. When I turn on white instead of turning rgb off it turns them to the all on composite white.

Do you have a SmartThings hub? There are several RGBW controllers that work withST that let you control the channels separately.

1 Like

Yes. I do it is still the second gen model but that shouldn’t matter. I recently bought the gledopto and it looks like this.

Now i’m confused on what you’re looking for. Are you looking to control the LED channels separately or are you looking for an LED strip that has the RGB diodes and the white diode on the same chip?

Sorry, I am good with the strips I have. They alternate rgb then warm white. I am wanting to have the option to change the color but when I turn to white only use the white channel and turn the rgb off. I have always hated the color you get with the composite white of the rgb. This controller acts great for all the colors except for white.

I am going to try the Zooz controller next and see if it has better results. Unless there is something I’m doing wrong.

The zooz can do that. I just setup one myself. but I am having problems with the RGB channels turning themselves off.

1 Like

fibaro rgbw latest relase isn’t working well at all, takes 1 min for color transition and presets like police lights are not working at all, my 2 year old controllers still work fine but 442 version that is few months old is useless currently

@JDRoberts
I found something while browsing called RGBIC. im not sure which is the best option but they have big differences in price.

Gove

TP-link

LIFX

the thing is i dont think these can exceed 10 meters ( i need 12 )
the tp-link is really exciting me. but I would really love to hear your opinions.

Anything for the UK market. Installed RGBW and Fibaro in August, just come to wire it up and now it doesn’t work properly :face_with_symbols_over_mouth: :face_with_symbols_over_mouth: :face_with_symbols_over_mouth:

Check the first post. Almost all of those devices are available for both the US and UK markets except the Zooz. Definitely gledopto, Sonoff, and rgbgenie are available in both. If you were looking specifically for zwave, though, you might be out of luck. :disappointed_relieved:

Yup, was ideally after Z-Wave :frowning:
I dont think any of those support RGBW though do they? Only RGB

Again, see the first post. As shown there, RGBGenie and Zemismart have some RGBW models, I’m not sure about Gledopto. But those are all zigbee.