Incorrect Lutron device state shown in app


I have my the lights at my front door controlled with a Lutron Caseta switch. I have an automation set so that the lights turn off at sunrise. A few weeks ago, the lights stopped turning off at sunrise…I see in the ST app that the lights show as “Off” when they’re actually on. If I open the Lutron app, however, they correctly show as “On.” It can’t be a connectivity issue because if I manually turn the lights off at the switch, they will still come on as programmed at sunset. I have tried deleting and re-adding the switch in ST but it did not correct the issue. The switch is only 20 feet away from the ST hub and one floor above.

Any ideas? Thanks in advance!