Google home AND Alexa?

Thanks for all the input. Got two more dots instead of GH

1 Like

Another GH con: no audio output.

Alexa is more mature when we’re talking about home automation, I like GH for casting video to my TV and of course I think GH is a little bit more conversational. To say that - I like both home assistant.

I am not sure if someone mention this trick but I have Alexa and GH next to each othe and if I want to cast videos to my TV when GH is not around. I use Alexa voice remote to cast the video or audio by using “SIMON SAYS, Okay Google play [video name] on my living room” > and it’s like magic video appear on my living room TV. :grin:

3 Likes

Had GH for 29 days side by side Echo for testing who gets to stay in my living room…

While Google has a slight advantage of being able to cast things on my TV, its current capabilities are pretty limited and cannot justify the form and capabilities of a Dot. With that said, neither Echo nor GH earned the place in my living room, but Amazon’s Alexa ecosystem wins big…GH is going back and replaced by two Dots, which will finalize my voice controlled whole house project.

Update: one of the decisive factors, was that Google Assistant is not widely available on the phones. I find myself talking to Alexa a lot using my phone than anything else, in the car, outside around the house or just when I am not near any of my Amazon gadgets. Alexa Listens on Android is Amazon’s best third party service!

1 Like

Funny you mentined, I used Echosistant to achieve the same thing without saying Simon says and with hands free…

I said Alexa tell Kitchen, OK Google play video on my TV and the Sonos spoke to GH and my boys got to watch the video…

3 Likes

Is echosistant what you use to make it speak to different rooms? Like if my kid is upstairs I can tell him to come via Alexa instead of yelling through the house ?

Yes, but you cannot push to another Alexa enabled device. You need to have a speaker capabale of playing text to speech messages like Sonos or other connected speakers…

I have an Echo Dot and a Sonos in every room…

2 Likes

Gotcha. Thank you

The future with those two at once can get complicated…

2 Likes

Last night, wife tries talking to Alexa, which is about 10 feet in front of us, direct line of sight, very little background noise:
Wife: "Alexa, turn the fireplace off:
Alexa: "I’m sorry, I don’t know how to help you with that.
Wife: "Alexa, turn the fireplace off"
Alexa: "I can’t find a device called Fire Stick in Chris’s account:

Wife (to our GH about 10 feet behind us, without turning to face it, same volume): "Ok Google, turn the fireplace off"
GH: “You got it, turning the fireplace off”

So you’re saying your GH is one-upper? I don’t doubt it a bit and I can’t blame Alexa for not liking it… Lol

1 Like

Totes maGoats!

Is there a bitterness/jealousy setting somewhere in Alexa’s options thst I can turn off?

1 Like

Just out of curiosity, is the bright portion of the illuminated ring in the position nearest to you when speaking to the Echo from that location? I’ve noticed that depending on placement of objects nearby and the resultant sound reflections (like when the device is on a nightstand near the headboard of a bed) sometimes the ‘dominant’ mic that is selected may be the furthest from your voice. Maybe some random echoes (!) are interfering with its reception.

1 Like

I’ve had some rare issues. This past week it’s been picking up the wake word in general conversation or something on TV. Not enough to get aggravated, but it’s expected I guess

1 Like

Seems to be about 50/50 whether the green portion is facing me or not. Could be a reflection issue I suppose.

That’s the opposite of my experience. Not with the gadgets, but with the wives :smiley:

Until I got these Echo dots just a couple weeks ago, I was using a tablet with OK google and my own custom phrases. And it had difficulty hearing me clearly, and because I had to repeat it frequently the wife was constantly making fun of it which made it even worse. But she’s now onboard with Alexa! The difference? The launch phrase. “OK google”, for some reason, just does not sit well with many people.

So for now I’m onboard with Alexa. It does everything I need it to do***. Though I would never have gotten onboard had I been required to get the $140 tube… When google changes form factor from a big Glade/Airwick thing to an unobtrusive little thing that I can stick on a wall, I will of course get one. Or two.

***Is your fireplace a zigbee/zwave item? Didn’t know they even made those lol

1 Like

It’s a DIY deal using a pocket socket and a SPST relay.

I’ve had a Google Home for about a month now and its great. I use the voice commands to turn my lights on and off with SmartThings. Its great for adding items to your shopping list on the fly, having it read you your schedule for the day, and playing music via the YouTube Red free 6 month trial.

I’ve also found that its a bit “smarter” than Alexa. For example I can ask “OK Google, what was the price of gold in September 1962?” and it will answer me. I can then ask “What about 1963?” and it knows I’ve just asked a follow up question to the initial question and returns an accurate answer. I played around with a buddy’s Echo and couldn’t get Alexa to behave that way. After Christmas I plan to implement my cameras and see what I can do with those.

In your situation I’m not sure theres too much difference between the Dot and GH. I plan to either get a second GH for upstairs or try an Echo.

After an outage and a reset Google home has duplicated everything. I managed to get all my devices working again with Google Home but haven’t been able to get routines working again. Solution was to get a Dot. Works fine. Bottom line- you can use both.